Kim Matula as Katherine

Ian Harding as Peter

Beth Leavel as Susan Kraine

Lori Tan Chinn as Arlene

Reginald VelJohnson as Roy

Kathleen Garrett as Mrs. Winchester

Christopher Innvar as Robert Baron

Kate MacCluggage as Lily Baron

Julian Gamble as Grampa Bob

Blair Baker as Charlie

Liana Hunt as Betsey

Jack Carter Barton as Teen Peter

Leo James Davis as Middle Peter

Christopher Riley as Young Peter

Stanton Nash as Bob

Meghan Grace O'Leary as Rachel

Kendyl Ito as Neighbor

JB Chen as Robert business associate

Juan Carlos Infante as Gabe

Anna Clare Kerr as Peter's mother (1956)

Austin Schoenfeld as Devon

Steve Antonucci as Valet (uncredited)

Warren Smith II as Carousel Kid (uncredited)

Sara McDermott as Ghost (uncredited)

Estavion White as Reporter (uncredited)