Lacey Chabert as Emily Melrose

Wes Brown as Jared

Peter Jacobson as Albert Melrose

Melissa Peterman as Pamela

Stephen Tobolowsky as Ned

Walter Platz as Bob

Ellen Travolta as Mary Louise

Kristoffer Polaha as Kevin

Eric Mabius as Allan

Jake Stormoen as Dan

Mario DeAngelis as Tree Lighting Ceremony Attendee (Uncredited)

Alireza Mirmontazeri as Neighbor (uncredited)

Carrie Morgan as Gail Melrose

Eliza Hayes Maher as Jess

Laura Wardle as Belinda

Lila Clark as Nicole

Charlotte Witt as Helen

Abby Villasmil as Young Emily

Manning Hazen as Young Jared

John Forker as Neighbor (uncredited)

Bebita Ndongo as Neighbor (Uncredited)

Mary Rice as Christmas Shopper (Uncredited)