Peter Sarsgaard as Floyd Monk

Billy Magnussen as Jay Horton

Sarah Gadon as Julie Horton

Skye P. Marshall as Mrs. Tidwell

Faran Tahir as Kaan

Kristine Nielsen as Ms. McMurray

Fisher Stevens as Upton Sinclair

Callum Vinson as Tom

Julia Ford Collier as Photographer / Thief (as Julia Collier)

Willa Dunn as Molly

Robert John Gallagher as Police Officer

Roy William Gardner as Mr. Monk

Mike Liscio as Burly Thief

John Posey as Sheriff

Joe Rashbaum as Gravedigger #1

Ali Wills as New maid