Blake Lively as Lily Bloom

Justin Baldoni as Ryle Kincaid

Jenny Slate as Allysa

Brandon Sklenar as Atlas Corrigan

Hasan Minhaj as Marshall

Kevin McKidd as Andrew Bloom

Amy Morton as Jenny Bloom

Alex Neustaedter as Young Atlas Corrigan

Isabela Ferrer as Young Lily Bloom

Robert Clohessy as Sheriff

Robin S. Walker as Doctor Johnson

Emily Baldoni as Doctor Julie

Adam Mondschein as Doctor Dunbar

Caroline Siegrist as Katie

Robyn Lively as Ms. Byland

Megan Robinson as Ms. Smith

Steve Monroe as Realtor

Daphne Zelle as Female Waiter