Matt Servitto as John

Lelia Symington as Emma

Delaney White as Jocelyn

Ken Arnold as Pastor Lewis

Mary Jane Pentony as Young Jocelyn

Michael Sheffield as The Jester

Sam Lukowski as Liquor Store Clerk

Lena Janes as Madison

Gabriel Morgan as Bryce

Mia Rae Roberts as Alexis

Jesse L. Green as Jimmie

Judson Grubby as Aiden

Joe Hansard as Larry

Juniper Grabia as Trick or Treater

Dan De Luca as Officer #1

Molly Bevetts as 911 Operator

Riley Collins as Young Emma

Faye Higdon as Grandmom

Emmanuel Kerry as Officer #2

Patrick McAteer as Officer #3

Olivia Miller as Trick or Treater

Carla Okouchi as Mom (voice)

Cory Okouchi as Bartender Frank

John Perin as Concession Man

Avery Polcari as Trick or Treater

Lennon Sanchez as Trick or Treater

Xander Timpane as Trick or Treater