Blayne Weaver as Tyler

Martin Starr as Alan

Natalie Morales as Sophie

Patrick J. Adams as Julian

Vanessa Branch as Wendy

John Michael Higgins as Paul

Dave Foley as Charles

Jaime Pressly as Claire

Brandon Barrera as Kenny

Kristina Klebe as Reese

Nate Rubin as Bookstore Teen

Samantha Shelton as Melissa

Lena Clark as Savannah

Sarah Jane Morris as Beth

Erin Cahill as Missy

David Giuntoli as Jared

Sheeri Rappaport as Kristi