Nick Offerman as Jerry Kane

Jacob Tremblay as Joe Kane

Dennis Quaid as John Bouchart

Kezia Dacosta as Candace

Terry J. Nelson as Deputy Sheriff

Bobby Gilchrist as Mr. Friedman

Megan Mullally as Beverly

Ruby Wolf as Jess Bouchart

Buddy Campbell as Bob

Tommy Kramer as Tommy Paulson

Jared Carter as Jared

Jennifer Nesbitt-Eck as Jennifer

Mike L. Thomas as Mike

Cheryl Vanwinkle as Cheryl

Jason Cochrane as Gun Salesman

Chris Greene as Officer Wray

Jade Fernandez as Brenda Reese

William Sherman as William

Astrid Allen as Astrid

Alonso Rappa as Teen #3

Martha Plimpton as Lesley Anne

Jason Scott Morgan as Ponytail

Thomas Mann as Adam Bouchart

John Trejo as Rodney

Brandon Stewart as Rob Everson

Barry Clifton as Judge Tate

Andrew Ortenberg as Courtroom Clerk

Nancy Travis as Patty Bouchart

Krishna Sistla Ward as Clerk

Julia Watts as School Registrar

Chris Pierce as Sheriff's Deputy

Tommy Dion Burns as Night Clerk

Patchez Black as Meeting Hall #4 Attendee (uncredited)

Julia D. Borkowski as Graduation Guest (uncredited)

Kyleigh Box as Grocery Store Shopper (uncredited)

Brandon Devine as Police Recruit (uncredited)

Leslie Dianne as Courtroom Gallery Audience Member

Phoenix Ghost as Motel 6 Manager

Mike Gross as Graduation Guest (uncredited)

Vu Ha as Deputy Sheriff (uncredited)

Bradley Hall as Detective background (uncredited)

Kevin Hill as Meeting All #4 Attendee (uncredited)

Tara Hollums as Funeral attendant (uncredited)

Mark Alan Jaeger as Meeting Hall Attendee (uncredited)

Jobie James as Casino Guest

Matthew Jaycox as State Trooper

Nathan Kirby as Feautered Background (uncredited)

Marilyn Knapp as Neighbor (uncredited)

Anna Knight as Grocery Store Shopper (uncredited)

Ed LaCerra as Background / Extra (uncredited)

Faron Ledbetter as State Trooper (uncredited)

Ben Matias as Restaurant Patron (uncredited)

Eric Parkinson as Father Michael (uncredited)

John Potthast as Detective

Paul Rolfes as Casino Guest (uncredited)

Brittany Seals as Mourner (uncredited)

Rick W. Stiles as Mourner / Friend (uncredited)

Laura Welkey as School Staff (uncredited)

Gabe Williams as Police Recruit (uncredited)