Sean Astin as Narrator

Mallory Everton as Cora / Townswoman

Whitney Call as Robert Failure Gladstone / Charlotte / Temperance

Matthew Meese as Captain Evander Lillianquist / Willy / Flour Man / Jeff

Jason Gray as Chesterton / Doctor / Proprietor / Kit Carson

Natalie Madsen as Aveline / Madam Molly

Stephen Meek as Elijah / William / Thirsty Man

Stacey Harkey as Terrence / Clarence / Fan #2 / The Ringmaster

Jeremy Warner as Hank / The Lion

Adam Berg as Percival / Polio Joe / Henry / Billy / Mime

James Perry as Angus / Julian / Johnny River / Fan #1 / Porch Man / Papa

Matt Moen as Strongman

Ruth Clarke as Johnny River Sr.

Molly Schofield as Sarah Jenkins

Macy Knapp as Teen Aveline

Miley Knapp as Young Aveline

Sonja Call as Grandma Jenkins

Alan Call as Grandpa Jenkins

Cruz Jolley as Jenkins Boy

Asher Chappell as Glenn the Ranch Hand

Chris Dwight as Assassin

Bryson Alejandro as Simon Bolivar

Chase Montierth as Poor Chap Elijah Refused to Carry Across the River

Lorymore Warner as First-born Son