Dan Blocker as Charley

Nanette Fabray as Sadie

Jim Backus as Staunch

Wally Cox as Mr. Bester

Jack Elam as Kittrick

Henry Jones as Hanson

Mickey Rooney as Indian Tom

Noah Beery Jr. as Eddie

Stubby Kaye as Bartender

Marge Champion as Mrs. Bester

Don 'Red' Barry as Rusty

Hamilton Camp as Mr. Fowler

Tom Basham as Traveler

Iron Eyes Cody as Crazy Foot

James McCallion as Dr. Henry

Byron Foulger as Reverend Marshall

Ray Ballard as Carson

Jack Cassidy as Roger Hand

Susan Saint James as Mrs. Martha Kid (uncredited)

Amzie Strickland as Hotel desk clerk (uncredited)

Charles Cirillo as Townsman (uncredited)

Sig Frohlich as Townsman (uncredited)

Bobby Gilbert as Townsman (uncredited)

Edwin Rochelle as Townsman (uncredited)

Christopher Shea as Boy holding sign (uncredited)

Eric Shea as Boy outside saloon (uncredited)

Olan Soule as Train Conductor (uncredited)