Kim Director as Kim Diamond

Jeffrey Donovan as Jeffrey "Jeff" Patterson

Erica Leerhsen as Erica Geerson

Tristine Skyler as Tristen Ryler

Stephen Barker Turner as Stephen Ryan Parker

Lanny Flaherty as Sheriff Cravens

Lauren Hulsey as Eileen Treacle

Raynor Scheine as Rustin Parr

Kennen Sisco as Peggy

Dina Napoli as Reporter

Joe Berlinger as Burkittsville Tourist

Pete Burris as MBI Man

Briton Green as Stoner

Anja Baron as Tourist

Kurt Loder as Kurt Loder

Chuck Scarborough as Chuck Scarborough

Conan O'Brien as Self (archive footage)

Andy Richter as Self (archive footage)

Bruce D. Reed as Burkittsville Resident #1

Sara Phillips as Burkittsville Tourist #2

Lynda Millard as Burkittsville Resident #2

Deb Burgoyne as Burkittsville Resident #3

Andrea Cox as Burkittsville Resident #4

Erik Jensen as Stoner #2

Peggy K. Chang as Foreigner #1

Tony Tsang as Foreigner #2

Kevin Murray as Doctor

Keira Naughton as Nurse

Ed Sala as MBI Man #2

Tyler Zeisloft as Teenager #1

Richard Kirkwood as Teenager #2

Justin Fair as Teenager #3

Brilane Bowman as Ham Lady

Robert M. Kelly as MBI Man #3

Landra Booker as Reporter, Fox 45

Jacqui Allen as Reporter

Sloane Brown as Reporter, WJZ 13

Karen Tsen Lee as (voice)

Heidi Burger as Print Reporter

Brian Dragonuk as Angry Citizen at Courthouse

Armen Garo as Doctor

Nasi Glekas as Security Guard

Cathy Haase as First Nurse

Oscar Haynes as Videographer

Rick Kain as On Camera News Reporter

Julie Mabry as Hiker in Woods

Martin Pfefferkorn as Mental Patient

Chad Ridgely as Photographer

Ryan Slattery as

Rei Hance as Heather Donahue (archive footage) (uncredited)

Joshua Leonard as Joshua Leonard (archive footage) (uncredited)

Michael C. Williams as Michael Williams (archive footage) (uncredited)

Justin Fair as Teenager #3