Rachael Leigh Cook as Erin

Sam Page as Sam

Patrick Thomas O'Brien as Chuck

Bailey Stender as Debbie

Ahmed Mawas as Archie

T. Mychael Rambo as Santa

Sarah Agnew as Mayor

Kathryn Fumie as Maria

Rod Kasai as Taylor

Mika Flanagan as Olivia

Melinda Kordich as Diana

Chase Marcotte as Jonah

Jim Cunningham as Lou

Greta Oglesby as N.P. General Counsel

Agatha Rae Pokrzywinski as Bakery Worker

Rae Dastoor as Bakery Owner

Jake Lieder as Radio Intern

Christina Goltare as Town Square Shopper (uncredited)

Gwen Ruhoff as Elf Council member (uncredited)

Dawan Scott as Tree Ceremony Attendee (uncredited)

Jesse Bakken as North Pole Elf (uncredited)

Bradley C. Daniels as Background (uncredited)

Mike Flaherty as Town Square Shopper (uncredited)

Julie Goulette as Coffee Shop Patron / Town Square Shopper (uncredited)

Dawn Jensen as Elf on Grand Council of Elves (uncredited)

Laura Judson as Santa's Elf (uncredited)

Tyler Kimber as Santa's Elf (uncredited)

Stacy Masog as Sleeping Woman in Jail (uncredited)

Emilio Medina as Santa's Elf (uncredited)

Chris Russ as Background (uncredited)

Amy Jo Schmidt as Elf Council Member (uncredited)

Lucretia Stillwater as Angry Woman in Jail (uncredited)