Eva Victor as Agnes Ward

Naomi Ackie as Lydie

Louis Cancelmi as Preston Decker

Kelly McCormack as Natasha

Lucas Hedges as Gavin

John Carroll Lynch as Pete

Hettienne Park as Eleanor Winston

E.R. Fightmaster as Fran

Cody Reiss as Devin

Jordan Mendoza as Logan

Anabel Graetz as Professor Wilkinson

Jonathan Myles as The Man She Thought Was Decker

Danny Diaz as Student

Marc Carver as Doctor

Liz Bishop as Elizabeth

Natalie Rotter-Laitman as Claire

Francesca D'Uva as Grocery Store Gianna

Alison Wachtler as Clerk

David J. Curtis as Judge

Priscilla Manning as Andrea Fuller

Kate Fitzgerald as Tracey Dover

Jesse Gabbard as Hector Woguard

Lucien Spelman as Kevin Faber

Tom Ford as Walter

Celeste Oliva as Sophie

Chhoyang Cheshatsang as Thomas

Conor Sweeney as Jeremy

Lensley Miles Adam as Baby Jane

Langston Shelby Moore as Baby Jane Double

Noochie the Cat as Olga the Cat

Eric Josif as Additional Voicework

Tierre Diaz as Juror (uncredited)

Casey McNeal as Juror (uncredited)

Jim Powers as Shopper (uncredited)

Debora Strout as Court Reporter (uncredited)