Michael Cimino as Cole

Peyton List as Bea

Phoebe Holden as Lydia

Andrea Navedo as Catarina

Brandon Micheal Hall as Mr. Porter

Christine M. Campbell as Teacher 1928

Ethan Herschenfeld as Julian - Tour Guide

Shivani Mendez as Amy - Real Estate Agent

Jesus-Papoleto Melendez as Older Man

Booch O'Connell as Cole's Bandmate

Samantha Everett as Disgruntled Party Guest

Sharleen Shayan as Girl 1

Taip Ceman as Nelson

Jason Kisare as Young Boy

PJ Adzima as Chet

Michael Castillejos as Cole's Dad

Chloé Guerin as Lydia (voice)

Justin Jasiewicz as Boy With Glasses

Ilda Mason as Young Woman

Raina Pellinger as Witch

Jaxon Platon as Pizza Boy

Sequoia Shayvonne as Gatsby Show Girl

Elaine Apruzzese as Pedestrian in 1928 (uncredited)

Bob Leszczak as Museum Guest (uncredited)