David Howard Thornton as Steamboat Willie

Allison Pittel as Selena

Amy Schumacher as Amber

Jesse Posey as Pete

Jarlath Conroy as Barry

Julia Schroeder as Dominique

Brian Scolaro as Captain Clark

Kailey Hyman as Cindi

Rumi C. Jean-Louis as Matteo

Poonam Basu as Jazzy

Stephanie Bates as Bella

Allie Seibold as Rory

Savannah Whitten as Ariana

Jarod Lindsey as Moses

Jesse Kove as Lieutenant Diaz

Michael Defilippis as First Mate Tommy

Jared Johnston as Neil

Tyler Posey as Radio Operator Mike

Brian Quinn as Mitch McEverly

Joe DeRosa as Paul Sanguino

Rachel Victoria Moore as Jamie

Peter Romano as Officer Chris

Buzz Roddy as Officer Pat O'Hare

Corey Militzok as Phillip Park

Jayme Woj as Deckhand Roscoe

Anthony E. Williams as Officer Martinez

Alexandra Acosta as Hilda

Charles Edwin Powell as Borough President Molinari

Tommy Bechtold as TJ

Tammi Cubilette as Liz

Michael Leavy as Deckhand Bert Brunswick

Jason Lockhart as Cyclist Peter

Ken Maharaj as Albert

Cassandra Ruiz as Frankie

Allyson Sereboff as Aubrey

Sarah Kopkin as Ilsa Arindel

Steven Della Salla as Charlie DeLorenzo

Gilbrando Acevedo as Shirtless Cowboy