Tim Robinson as Craig Waterman

Kate Mara as Tami Waterman

Jack Dylan Grazer as Steven Waterman

Paul Rudd as Austin Carmichael

Rick Worthy as Mr. Mendoza

Whitmer Thomas as Ian

Daniel London as Stan

Eric Rahill as Mike

Jacob Ming-Trent as Nathan

Billy Bryk as Tony

Meredith Garretson as Bianca

Ari Dalbert as James

Josh Segarra as Devon

Raphael Sbarge as Garrett

Omar Torres as Jared

Jason Veasey as Zed

Jon Glaser as Big Sam

Carmen Christopher as Jimp

Mike J. Mills as Small Jon

Alex Webb as Mayor Nichols

Juri Henley-Cohn as Jerry the Client

Desi Waters as Moderator

Brandi Burkhardt as Rebecca Springs

Andhy Méndez as Officer Whitmer

John Cenatiempo as Detective Persons

Teren Carter as Lieutenant James

Ivy Wolk as Jen Peyser

Conner O'Malley as Patton

Craig Frank as Buzz

James Daly as K9 Cop