Anne Judson-Yager as Whittier Smith

Bree Turner as Tina Hammersmith

Kevin Cooney as Dean Sebastian

Faune Chambers Watkins as Monica Jones

Bryce Johnson as Greg

Richard Lee Jackson as Derek

Bethany Joy Lenz as Marni Potts

Holly Towne as Janice

Dennis Hemphill Jr. as Francis

Felicia Day as Penelope

Katherine Bailess as Colleen Lipman

Joshua Gomez as Sammy Stinger

Kelly Stables as Tiny Blonde

Brian Patrick Wade as Fatneck

Darren Geare as Croquet Teammate

Francesca Caro as Whittier's Mom

Oscar Orosco as Oscar

Paul Collins as Voice

Chris Carmack as Todd

Derek Richardson as Party Guy

Jerry Trainor as Smug Guy

Lamya Jezek as Party Girl

Christopher Emerson as Croquet Guy

Geoff Stults as Football Player

Rossi Morreale as Keg Guy

Nicole Albright as Cheerleader

Maria Carmen as Cheerleader

Eric Claxton as Cheerleader

Eric Correia as Cheerleader

Jonathan Dahl as Cheerleader

Tannaz Emamjomeh as Cheerleader

Michelle Heitzler as Cheerleader

Mindy Kantner as Cheerleader

Nito Larioza as Cheerleader

Sasha Leitch as Cheerleader

Jorene Leonard as Cheerleader

Jonathan Lewis as Cheerleader

Jeff McQueen as Cheerleader

Tim Passalacqua as Cheerleader

Rhonda Roberts as Cheerleader

Stanton Parker Smith as Cheerleader

Monica Soto as Cheerleader

Julianne Waters as Cheerleader

Owen-John Williams as Cheerleader

Zachary Woodlee as Cheerleader

Stacey Walker as Cheerleader

Rafael Jordan as DJ