Britt Robertson as Ashley

Chad Michael Murray as Luke

Marla Sokoloff as Marie

Marc Anthony Samuel as Rodger

Maxwell Caulfield as Danny

Colt Prattes as Troy

Hector David Jr. as Ricky

Michael Gross as Stan

Beth Broderick as Lily

María Canals-Barrera as Denise

Meredith Thomas as Jodie

Rivkah Reyes as Raquel

Dominique Domingo as Samantha

Bella Shepard as Shelby

Michael Gaglio as Mike

Katie A. Keane as Riley

Chuck Spitler as Santa

Adrian Gaeta as Dakota

Gizmo Nolan as Gizmo

Skyler Altman as Jingle Belle

Kylie Rose James as Jingle Belle

Sydney Kinney as Jingle Belle

Kellyann Lennon as Jingle Belle

Mia Lally Maxwell as Jingle Belle

Gabby Rosales as Jingle Belle

Alexis Tillman as Jingle Belle