Johnny Francis Wolf as Gabe Snow

Megan Pearson as Noel Snow

Michael Brecher as Ed (Chief Editor)

Joseph L. Johnson as Pete

Eric Messner as Mall Santa

Lisa Oberg as Frost

Monalisa Arias as Evil Elf

Annika Backstrom as Evil Elf

Tara Chiusano as Evil Elf

Melissa Dunphy as Evil Elf

Jessica Perkins II as Evil Elf

Katie Lawson as Evil Elf

Alexxus Young as Silent Knight (Evil Nun)

Kelly Cardall as Silent Knight (Evil Nun)

Jamie Wozny as Silent Knight (Evil Nun)

Seth Herzog as Tiny Tim

Theo Franz as Young Gabe

Lily Franz as Gabe's Sister

Josh Buchbinder as Clausferatu

Trent Gates as Gabe's Father

Colin Barnhill as Santa Claus

Leanna Chamish as Gabe's Mom, Mrs. Snow

John Saba as Priest (voice)