Genevieve Hannelius as Charity (voice)

Tatiana Gudegast as Hope (voice) / Front Teeth Girl

Marlowe Peyton as Jingle (voice)

Aidan Gemme as Noble (voice)

Cheryl Ladd as Mrs. Claus

Danny Woodburn as Eli

Richard Kind as Eddy the Elf Dog (voice)

Josh Feldman as Carter Reynolds

Kaitlyn Maher as Sarah Reynolds

George Newbern as Thomas Reynolds

Trevor Wright as Baxter (voice)

Obba Babatundé as Mayor Denny

Ali Hillis as Agnes Bright

Jennifer Elise Cox as Blue Bright

Audrey Wasilewski as Dorothy Bright

Bill Chott as Mr. Holman

Paul Rae as Jeb Gibson

Brian T. Finney as Sheriff Andy

Ted Rooney as Mr. Miller

Diedrich Bader as Comet (voice)

Chris Coppola as Dancer (voice)

Josh Flitter as Brutus (voice)

Bryce Clyde Jenkins as Emmett

Pat Finn as Santa Claus

Tom Everett Scott as Santa Paws (voice)

Bonnie Somerville as Mrs. Paws (voice)

Jay Brazeau as Judge

Joey Bothwell as Mildred

Nic Novicki as Ellis

Michael Teigen as Mr. Kent