Cole Escola as Fifi / Juliette / Samuel / Aunt Ida / Preacher / Ms. Evelyn / Prospector

Matt Barats as Actor

Gavin Hudson Berman as Harper

Aidy Bryant as Gloria

Rebecca Rose Bulnes as "Out West Player"

Colin Burgess as "Out West Player"

Francesca D'Uva as Senator

Orlando Dole as "Out West Player"

Sean Finnigan as "Out West Player"

Jo Firestone as Actress

Erin Markey as Mrs. Hawk

Conner O'Malley as Angry Ice Cream Cowboy

Joe Penczak as Arnold

Richard Perez as Luke

Eudora Peterson as Anne

Macy Rodman as Melody

Zach Schiffman as "Out West Player"

Lauren Servideo as Thomas Bentley's Fiancée

Chloe Troast as "Out West Player"

Ikechukwu Ufomadu as Sheriff Thomas Bentley

Kate Weiman as Clara

Amy Sedaris as Old Woman

Justin Vivian Bond as Narrator (voice)