Christine Taylor as Annabelle Wahl

William Morgan Sheppard as Kris Kringle

Christopher Wiehl as Mark Stafford

Lin Shaye as Zelda

Shashawnee Hall as Mayor Phil Green

Michael Chieffo as Hank

Vivica A. Fox as Zoe Marsden

Tony Cicchetti as Jake

John Farley as Lloyd

Joshua Snyder as Brian Wahl

Angela Pierce as Dr. Nora

John Kapelos as Harley

Katy Stoll as Carly

Kristin Burke as Betty Anne Clark

Jonathan Spencer as Jonathan

Laura Niemi as Emily

Chris Farah as Sarah

Tate Berney as Owen