Hilarie Burton as Krissy Kringle

Matt Dallas as Lance

Gabriel Tigerman as Marco

Dana Barron as Brenda Weir

Danneel Ackles as Jill Rhodes

Tony Cavalero as Justin Reid

Meredith Baxter as Carol Kringle

Michael Gross as Walter Kringle

Jessica Tuck as Debbie O'Brien

Michelle Hurd as Helen Purcell

Googy Gress as Santa Claus

Steven Christopher Parker as Peter

Emily Arlook as Brittany

Sarena Khan as Tiffany

Stewart Scott as Stewie

Wade Williams as Bill

Anita Finlay as Mrs. Harris

Kaden Gibson as Fiesty Kid

Tony Denman as Cashier

Beth Harvey as Mother

Candace Kita as News Anchor

Weston McClelland as Santa Line Kid