Sam Hennings as Benjamin Steed

Brenda Strong as Mary Ann Steed

Eric Johnson as Joshua Steed

Alexander Carroll as Nathan Steed

Brighton Hertford as Melissa Steed

Kimberly Varadi as Becca Steed

Colin Ford as Matthew Steed

Sarah Bastian as Lydia Steed

Emily Podleski as Jessica Roundy

Jim Grimshaw as Josiah McBride

Jonathan Scarfe as Joseph Smith

Melanie Hawkins as Emma Smith

Frank Ashmore as Martin Harris

Curtis Andersen as Carl Rogers

Jeff Ham as Obadiah Cornwell

Giulia Pagano as Mother Smith

Raphael Sbarge as Parley Pratt

Mike Pniewski as Wilson Everett

Matthew Carlton as George Simpson

Michael Bowen as Robert Johnson

Caitlin Bradbury as Mary Partridge

David Dwyer as William Phelps

R. D. Call as Boggs

Milton Bagby as Caleb, Farmer

Danny Nelson as Reverend Samuel Bogart

Andrew Bowen as Brigham Young

Haynes Brooke as Edward Partridge

Nakotah LaRance as Pidgeon

Russell Durham Comegys as Ruffian

John Henry Scott as Deputy Frank

Adam Heffernan as Deputy Smiley

Don Henderson Baker as Ezra Booth

Annie Abbott as Edith Gates

Wilbur Fitzgerald as Magistrate

Mark Scarboro as Newell K. Whitney

Mary Tanner Bailey as Elsa Johnson

Stephen Michael Ayers as Father Smith

Rowan Arlo Bishop as Infant Joseph Smith

Kati Massey as Little Girl on Snow Trail

Brett Taylor as Man Crossing Street

William David Witt as Temple Builder

Barry J. Miller as Mormon Immigrant (uncredited)

William J. Mode as Militiaman / Tavern Patron / Citizen (uncredited)