Wes Brown as Jared Farnsworth

Lacey Chabert as Emily Melrose

Stephen Tobolowsky as Ned Broadhead

Melissa Peterman as Pamela Bevans

Ellen Travolta as Mary Louise

Kimberly J. Brown as Luna

Daniel Kountz as Marvin

Laura Wardle as Belinda

Walter Platz as Bob

Peter Jacobson as Albert

Richard Christy as Bucky

Carrie Morgan as Gail

Charlotte Witt as Helen

Eliza Hayes Maher as Jess

Lila Clark as Nicole

Ashley Whelan as Ashlynn Ashworth

Laurie Harrop-Purser as Grandma Melrose

Abby Villasmil as Young Emily

Manning Hazen as Young Jared