Jeffrey Hunter as Timothy Higgins

Preston Foster as Judge Homer Black

James Coburn as Boyd Palmer

Joanna Moore as Rita Dillard

Edward Andrews as Hyde

Kevin Hagen as John Dillard

Martin West as Stonewall Grey

Ed Nelson as Cole Marteen

Karl Swenson as Sheriff

Grace Lee Whitney as Texas Rose

Claude Stroud as Harvey Sprager

Sherwood Price as George Taggart

Arthur Malet as Barney

Marjorie Bennett as Mrs. Warren

Chuck Hicks as US Marshal Chuck (uncredited)

George DeNormand as Attorney Smith (uncredited)

Rod McGaughy as Attorney Dunaway (uncredited)

George Ford as Attorney Mullaney (uncredited)

William Fawcett as Tatum (uncredited)

Jim Hayward as Titus Gallagher (uncredited)

Charles Morton as Bartender (uncredited)

Chester Hayes as Stilt Walker (uncredited)

Orville Sherman as Ted Dooley (uncredited)

Jeffrey Sayre as Hotel Guest (uncredited)

Jerry Brown as Wagon Driver (uncredited)

Emile Avery as Stage Driver (uncredited)

Charles Seel as Mr. Steers (uncredited)

King Mojave as Juror (uncredited)

Jim Whitecloud as Trial Spectator (uncredited)

Waclaw Rekwart as Trial Spectator (uncredited)

Noble 'Kid' Chissell as Townsman (uncredited)

Michael Jeffers as Townsman (uncredited)

John Pedrini as Townsman (uncredited)

Charles McQuary as Townsman (uncredited)