Alan Rickman as Eli Michaelson

Bryan Greenberg as Barkley Michaelson

Shawn Hatosy as Thaddeus James

Eliza Dushku as City Hall

Bill Pullman as Max Mariner

Mary Steenburgen as Sarah Michaelson

Danny DeVito as Gastner

Ted Danson as Harvey Parrish

Ernie Hudson as Bill Canega

Lindy Booth as Beth Chapman

Tracey Walter as Simon Ahrens

Hal B. Klein as Tully's Guy

Matt Winston as Book Store Manager

Kirk Baily as Wil Cavalere

Joyce Guy as Eileen Moses

Kevin West as Jaundice Guy

Wayne Lopez as Cabbie

Dawn Balkin as Stewardess

Johanna Torell as Analea Sigvatsson

Mark Famiglietti as Officer Relyea

Juliette Jeffers as Claire

Greg Collins as Foreman

Danika Quinn as Opera Singer

Kelly Lange as Kelly Lange

Sam Rubin as Sam Rubin

Mary Pat Gleason as Ruby

Matthew Kimbrough as Deacon

Reid Collums as Delivery Guy

Larry Hankin as Dr. Polaczek

Lucy DeVito as Devotee

Dean Rader Duval as Ernie

Marina Black as Female Student

Joe Koons as Poet (uncredited)