Rachel McAdams as Colee Dunn

Tim Robbins as Fred Cheaver

Michael Peña as T.K. Poole

Annie Corley as Jeanie Klinger

John Diehl as Tom Klinger

John Heard as Bob

Molly Hagan as Pat Cheaver

Spencer Garrett as Pastor Nolan

Arden Myrin as Barbara Tilson

Katherine LaNasa as Janet

Kirk B.R. Woller as Army Psychologist

Mark L. Young as Scott Cheaver

Kerry Bishé as College Girl

Howard Platt as Stan Tilson

Coburn Goss as Peter Tilson

Jennifer Joan Taylor as Bob's Wife

Sarah Steele as Girl with Jacket