Robert De Niro as Lorenzo Anello

Chazz Palminteri as Sonny LoSpecchio

Lillo Brancato as Calogero 'C' Anello (Age 17)

Francis Capra as Calogero 'C' Anello (Age 9)

Taral Hicks as Jane Williams

Kathrine Narducci as Rosina Anello

Clem Caserta as Jimmy Whispers

Alfred Sauchelli, Jr. as Bobby Bars

Frank Pietrangolare as Danny K.O.

Joe Pesci as Carmine

Robert D'Andrea as Tony Toupee

Eddie Montanaro as Eddie Mush

Fred Fischer as JoJo 'The Whale'

Dave Salerno as Frankie Coffeecake

Joseph D'Onofrio as Slick (Age 17)

Luigi D'Angelo as Aldo (Age 17)

Louis Vanaria as Crazy Mario (Age 17)

Dominick Rocchio as Ralphie (Age 17)

Patrick Borriello as Slick (Age 9)

Paul Perri as Crazy Mario (Age 9)

Mitch Kolpan as Detective Belsik

Phil Foglia as Detective Vella

Max Genovino as Louie Dumps

Ralph Napolitano as Gino

Steve Kendall as Red Beard

A.J. Ekoku as A.J.

Sobe Bailey as Willy

Domenick Lombardozzi as Nicky Zero

Gianna Ranaudo as Tina

Nicky Blair as Jerry

Nina von Arx as Rachel

Derrick Simmons as Angry Neighbor

Richard DeDomenico as Priest

David Batiste as Angry Neighbor

Positive K as Protester (uncredited)