Emma Greenwell as Charlotte

Joe Egender as Brother Billy

Cameron Richardson as Sister Sheila

Roger Aaron Brown as Brother Cole

Elisa Aldridge as Brother Billy's Bride

Jason Benjamin as Brother Edgar

Don Harvey as Brother Sherman

James Lowe as Smiling Bobby

Brendan McCarthy as Wayne

Jayne Entwistle as Sister Nancy

Jalen Camp as Mordecai

Buffy Charlet as Liz

Sydney Bell as Congregation Member

Megan Ely as Congregation Member

Karen B. Greer as Congregation Member

Hank Quillen as Congregation Member