Zoe Kazan as Laurel / Audrey

Jake Johnson as Basel

Ron Livingston as Charles

Danny Pudi as Dr. Rao

Sterling Beaumon as Hunter

John Carroll Lynch as Frank

Frankie Shaw as Claudia

Sabrina Lloyd as Edith

Jeremy Howard as James

Shae D'Lyn as May

Bronwyn Cornelius as Perfect Mom

Patrick Breen as Perfect Dad

Stuart Littlefield as Perfect Boy

Rosa Yelena Schorr as Perfect Girl

Luka Jones as Patrick

Dale Raoul as Mrs. Shoemacher

Mark Kelly as Ralph

Jennifer Lafleur as Marguerite

Devan Leos as Funeral Boy #1

William Kronfeld as Funeral Boy #2

Luke Colombero as Peter

Tyler Nunes as Halloween Kid

Joey Fernandes as Halloween Kid

Vincent Castro as Halloween Kid

Luke Trujillo as Halloween Kid

Isiah Greene as Halloween Kid

Zeve Zilberberg as Halloween Kid