Randolph Scott as Vance

Robert Ryan as Sundance Kid

Anne Jeffreys as Cheyenne

George 'Gabby' Hayes as John Pettit

Jacqueline White as Madge Allen

Steve Brodie as Cole Younger

Tom Keene as Jim Younger

Robert Bray as John Younger

Lex Barker as Emmett Dalton

Walter Reed as Bob Dalton

Michael Harvey as Grat Dalton

Dean White as Billy the Kid

Robert Armstrong as Wild Bill Doolin

Tom Tyler as Wild Bill Yeager

Lew Harvey as Arkansas Kid

Gary Gray as Johnny

Walter Baldwin as Muley Wilson

Minna Gombell as Emily

Warren Jackson as George Mason

Robert Clarke as Dave

Jason Robards Sr. as Judge Harper

Charles Stevens as Grey Eagle