Richard Dreyfuss as Bobby Bartellemeo / Narrator

Burt Reynolds as Joey 'Bats' Pistella

Dan Hedaya as Mike 'The Brick' Donatelli

Seymour Cassel as Tony 'Mouth' Donato

Carrie-Anne Moss as Detective Olivia Neal

Jennifer Tilly as Ferris 'aka Maureen' Lowenstein

Lainie Kazan as Pepper Lowenstein

Miguel Sandoval as Raul Ventana, Drug Lord

Jeremy Piven as Det. Steve Menteer

Casey Siemaszko as Young Bobby Bartellemeo

Matt Borlenghi as Young Joey 'Bats' Pistella

Billy Jayne as Young Tony 'Mouth' Donato

Jeremy Ratchford as Young Mike 'The Brick' Donatelli

Louis Lombardi as Jimmy Whistles

Frank Vincent as Marty

Joseph Rigano as Old Gangster

Lorri Bagley as Sofa Girl

Oscar Isaac as Pal in Restaurant Kitchen

Al Quinn as Hospital Patient

Thomas Rosales Jr. as Ventana’s Gangster in the ship

Mike Moroff as Jorge

José Zúñiga as Escobar

Carlos Gómez as Miguel, Ventana's Man

Louis Guss as Jerry 'The Hammer' Fungo

Ron Karabatsos as Fat Pauly

Marc Macaulay as Driver

Cullen Douglas as Young Man

Jim R. Coleman as Paramedic

Vince Cecere as Wiseguy #1

Dana Daurey as Model Girl

Hope Pomerance as Realtor

Christy Tummond as Girl #2

Evelyn Brooks as Grandmother

Don Clark Williams as Elderly Husband

Jill Beach as Newscaster

Antoni Corone as Officer

Ian Marioles as Security Guard

Fyvush Finkel as Sol Lowenstein

Mal Jones as Dr. Ward, Medical Examiner

Ru Flynn as Mommy

Gino Salvano as Raul Guy #2

Elizabeth Powers as Girl

Jay Cannistraci as Tommy 'Shakes'

John Archie as Doctor

Christa Campbell as Nurse

Adam Cronan as Burger King Manager

Judith Delgado as Judge

Allan F. Nicholls as Wiseguy #3

Fabián Hernández as Bus Boy

Susie Park as Asian Masseuse

Carlo Allen as Latino Mobster

George Fisher as Tony the Torch

Harry Boykoff as Louie the Lip

Tamela D'Amico as Gina

Alfonso DiLuca as Charlie

Heidi Rae as Showgirl

Ron Madoff as Extra