Drew Barrymore as Amy Fisher

Tony Denison as Joey Buttafuoco

Harley Jane Kozak as Amy Pagnozzi

Tom Mason as Eric Naiburg

Laurie Paton as Mary Jo Buttafuoco

Ken Pogue as Elliot Fisher

Linda Darlow as Roseann Fisher

Gabe Khouth as Tim Russo

Garry Davey as Detective

Dwight McFee as Daniel Severin

Philip Granger as Williams

Walter Marsh as Judge Marvin Goodman

Terry King as Fred Klein

Charles Siegel as Marvyn Kornberg

Lindsay Bourne as Ed Grilli

Michael Gabriel as Peter Guagenti

Philip Maurice Hayes as Paul Makely

Kim Kondrashoff as John

Terry David Mulligan as Rafael Aramovitz

Robin Mossley as Doctor