Kara Hayward as Emily Parris

Georgie Henley as Mary Warren

Olivia DeJonge as Lavinia Hall

Laura Fraser as Rose Hall

Kal Penn as Gordy Gambhir

Louis Ozawa as Stanley Huang

Morgan Turner as Sarah

Willa Cuthrell-Tuttleman as Catherine Huang

Gary Wilmes as Principal Harvey

Neal Huff as Tom

Hudson Yang as Henry Huang

Juliana Sass as Hilda

Evan Kuzma as Jeff

Orlagh Cassidy as Linda Warren

Deema Aitken as Travis

Quinn Baganz as Mike

Brian Berrebbi as Kingston Chronicle Journalist

Sonnie Brown as Grace Huang

David Chen as Gong-Gong

Annie Creech as Mary - Reenactment Scene

Nate Dern as Interviewer

Andrew Garman as

Grace Gray as Kandy Kane

Aubrey Hays as Lavinia - Reenactment Scene

Jessica Hecht as Sue Parris

Elisabeth Henry-Macari as Mrs. Olson

Mela Hudson as Secret Sisterhood Girl

Birgit Huppuch as Radio Host

Valentina Hurtado as Tara

Abby Quinn as Tanya

Hannah Munson as Jennifer

Lily Autumn Page as Lindsey

Wayne Pyle as Hilda's Dad

Amy Lynn Stewart as Reporter

Matt Walton as Reporter

Lindsay Andretta as High School Girl #1 (uncredited)

Ocean Elizabeth Currier as High School Girl #2 (uncredited)

Marilyn Fu as Woman Dressed as Ghost (uncredited)

Rosemary Howard as Shakespeare Audience (uncredited)

Donna Sue Jahier as Reporter (uncredited)

Phillip X. Levine as Proud Parent (uncredited)

William Todd Levinson as PTA Meeting Attendee (uncredited)

Steven Millhauser as Mr. Barry (uncredited)

Steven Patrick O'Connor as Reporter (uncredited)

Michael Patrick Burke as Cop (uncredited)

Laurent Rejto as Journalist (uncredited)

Harry L. Seddon as Reporter (uncredited)

Christina Venuto as High School Girl #3 (uncredited)

Benita Zahn as Extra (uncredited)