Jack Nicholson as Charley Partanna

Kathleen Turner as Irene Walker

Robert Loggia as Eduardo Prizzi

John Randolph as Angelo 'Pop' Partanna

William Hickey as Don Corrado Prizzi

Lee Richardson as Dominic Prizzi

Michael Lombard as Rosario Filargi " Finlay "

Anjelica Huston as Maerose Prizzi

Lawrence Tierney as Lt. Hanley

CCH Pounder as Peaches Altamont

Ann Selepegno as Amalia Prizzi

Vic Polizos as Phil Vittimizzare

Dick O'Neill as Bluestone

Sully Boyar as Casco Vascone

Antonia Vasquez as Theresa Prizzi

Tomasino Baratta as Opera Singer

John Calvani as Don's Bodyguard

Murray Staff as Gallagher

Joseph Ruskin as Marxie Heller

Raymond Serra as Bocca

Seth Allen as Alvin Gomsky

Dominic Barto as Presto Ciglione

Teddi Siddall as Beulah

Tom Signorelli as Photographer #2

Ray Iannicelli as Photographer #1

Stanley Tucci as Soldier

Themi Sapountzakis as Policeman

Debra Kelly as Bride at Mexican Chapel

Scott Campbell as Groom at Mexican Chapel

Beth Raines as Airport Clerk

Michael Sabin as Charley Partanna at 17

Michael Tuck as Anchorman "Fred"

Michael Fischetti as Kiely

Kenneth Cervi as Bodyguard

Marlene D. Williams as Mrs. Calhane

Joe Kopmar as Cigar Smoker #1

Erasmus C. Alfano as Cigar Smoker #2

Peter D'Arcy as Cigar Smoker #3

Thomas Lomanco as Cigar Smoker #4

Bill Brecht as Cigar Smoker #5

Enzo Citarelli as Priest

John P. Codiglia as Cop

Henry Fehren as Bishop

Alexandra Ivanoff as Soprano Soloist in Church

Skip O'Brien as Bartender

Theodore Theoharous as Priest

Jonathan L. Arland as Man #1 at Mexican Wedding

Rubén C. González as Man #2 at Mexican Wedding

Luis Accinelli as Man #3 at Mexican Wedding

Danielle Frederick as Woman #1 at Mexican Wedding

Garry Pastore as Usher #2 (Uncredited)

Nick Vallelonga as Arsonist (uncredited)