Rebecca Hall as Hannah Miles

Jason Sudeikis as Andrew McDonnell

Dianna Agron as Finley

Blythe Danner as Ellen Jespersen

Griffin Dunne as Upton

Joe Manganiello as Curtis

Maggie Castle as Shannon Jespersen

Richard Masur as Bruce Jespersen

Alex Quijano as Ben

Gabe Gibbs as Ethan Woodcock

Mary-Bonner Baker as Heidi

Damien Jurado as Hunter

Matthew Delamater as Seth Jespersen

Melissa Jesser as Melissa

Claire Skowronek as Megan

Frank Omar as Reggie

John Hickson as Al