Justin Ament as James Conners

William Sadler as Thomas Conners

Daniel Baldwin as Mr. McKinley

Ines Dali as Velma

Angus Macfadyen as Will Tunney

Marnie Alton as Mary Cooper

Tonantzin Carmelo as Miakoda

Shawn Reaves as Johny Cooper

Charles Napier as Sheriff Sanders

Dean Alioto as Spider

Michael Spears as Washakie

Anthony Michael Jones as Charlie

Courtney Gains as Finch

Timothy Patrick Cavanaugh as JD Harison

Nigel Daly as Garrick Haring

Tommy Giavocchini as Griffiths

Fred Griffith as Marshall

Zach Selwyn as Deputy Brian

Ross Hagen as Missionary

Christian Fortune as Young James

Devin Brochu as Young Johnny

Stephanie Patton as Young Mary

Trish Moreno as Mrs. Lane

Ricky Dean Logan as Towns Person