Ron Perlman as Jacob Shuler

Ken Olin as Jim Sandler

Jill Eikenberry as Susan

Gregg Henry as Sheriff Woodman

Nicholas Pryor as Baxter

Brad Pitt as Teddy Johnson

Maureen Mueller as Sarah Shuler

Noble Willingham as Judge Manning

Peter Michael Goetz as Keller

Theodore Bikel as Abe Moser

Olivia Burnette as Rachel

Bill Allen as Roy

Joey Popp as Juror(uncredited)

Noon Orsatti as (uncredited)

Katelyn Lord as Jim and Susan's Infant(uncredited)

Greg Gault as (uncredited)

Clay Boss as (uncredited)

Diane Moose Benfield as Funeral Party Member(uncredited)

Kay Gerhard as Townswoman

Lowndes B. Grier as Male Reporter

Ashley Bell as Female Reporter

Regina Bridges as Amish Woman

John Carl Shore as Bailiff

Linda Pierce as Young Woman

David Parker as Judge

Dale Wright as Court Clerk

Kay Joyner as Betty

Rick Warner as Cooper's Lawyer

Bob Hannah as Mr. Cooper

Michael Mattick as Peter Shuler

James G. Martin Jr. as Deputy Dave Lawson

Max Tucker as David Sandler

Judy Simpson as Mrs. Ames(as Judy Simpson Cook)

James Eric as Mr. Ames

Mert Hatfield as Mr. Grant

Michael Johnston as

Michael Flannery as Paul Cooper(as Michael Johnston)

Michael Criscuolo as Phillip Carr

Debby Severs as T.V. Reporter

Faye Brenner as Woman at Gas Station(uncredited)

Jody Smith as Warren

Leslie Riley as Pam