Paul Bates as Additional reindeer voices

Brenda Blethyn as Aunt Millie

Brittany Bristow as Erin Scott-Pierce

Leif Bristow as Blitzen (voice)

Jacqueline Byers as Skating girl (as Jackie Byers)

J. Miles Dale as Additional reindeer voices

Tony Daniels as Additional reindeer voices

Len Carlson as Additional reindeer voices

Josh Buckle as Jack Andrews

Wendii Fulford as Beth Cameron

Whoopi Goldberg as Blizzard (voice)

Samantha Hayes as (voice)

Ellen-Ray Hennessy as Delphi (voice)

Gary Johnston as Bobby's Father

Demetrius Joyette as Bobby Jackson

Stephanie Morgenstern as Emma Ward

J.D. Nicholsen as Ted Andrews

Aidan O'Hara as Derek Tynan

Jennifer Pisana as Jess Cameron

Christopher Plummer as Santa Claus

Kevin Pollak as Archimedes

Diana Reis as Sarah Andrews / Principal

Mark Rendall as Joe Andrews

Albert Schultz as Mr. Cameron - Jess's father

Lee Smart as Donner Jr. (voice)

Cree Summer as Aphrodite (voice)

Jan Tříska as Otto Brewer / Trainer

Zoe Warner as Katie Andrews

Jonathan Whitaker as Jordan Scott-Pierce

Jonathan Wilson as Jeremy

Richard Yearwood as Lucius

LeVar Burton as Night Watchman Elf (uncredited)

Marie V. Cruz as Santa's Elf (uncredited)