Gene Tierney as Lucy Muir

Rex Harrison as Capt. Daniel Gregg

George Sanders as Miles Fairley

Edna Best as Martha Huggins

Vanessa Brown as Anna Muir as an Adult

Anna Lee as Mrs. Fairley

Robert Coote as Mr. Coombe

Natalie Wood as Anna Muir as a Child

Isobel Elsom as Angelica Muir

Victoria Horne as Eva Muir

Stuart Holmes as Man Ordered Out of Train Compartment by Captain (uncredited)

Houseley Stevenson as Gardener (uncredited)

Helen Freeman as Author Displaced by Lucy (uncredited)

Whitford Kane as Sproule - London Publisher (uncredited)

Buster Slaven as Enquiries at Sproule's (uncredited)

Will Stanton as Porter (uncredited)

William Stelling as Bill - Anna's Fiance (uncredited)

David Thursby as Mr. Scroggins (uncredited)

Heather Wilde as Fairley Maid (uncredited)