Andrea Bowen as Rachel Sandler

Jennie Garth as Sarah Bennett

Erik von Detten as Jason

S. Epatha Merkerson as Ariel Winters

Nathan Anderson as Tim Willey

Evan Gamble as Greg Markwell

Rhoda Griffis as Karen Sandler

Andrew Matthews as Mark

Caroline McKinley as Sandra Markwell

Corey Flaspoehler as Randy Newell

Laura Slade Wiggins as Lindsey Carter

Scott M. King as High School Student (uncredited)