Margaret O'Brien as Midge

Robert Preston as Rev. Philip Y. Andrews

Danny Thomas as Cantor David Irwin Feldman

George Murphy as Patrick O'Donnell

Karin Booth as Florence Bartlett

Edward Arnold as Judge Martin O. Abercrombie

Jackie 'Butch' Jenkins as Louis Keller

Betty Garrett as Shoo Shoo Grady

Lotte Lehmann as Mama Feldman

Connie Gilchrist as Martha

Page Cavanaugh as Trio Leader (as Page Cavanaugh Trio)