Mark Duplass as Ethan

Elisabeth Moss as Sophie

Ted Danson as Therapist

Kiana Cason as Waitress

Kaitlyn Dodson as Diner Patron

Lori Farrar as Diner Patron

Marlene Malin as Diner Patron

Tim Peddicord as Diner Patron

Ryan Pederson as Diner Patron

Brett Bietz as Doug (voice)

Sean O'Malley as Dave (voice)

Mary Steenburgen as Mom (voice)

Drew Langer as Brett (voice)

Jennifer Spriggs as Ellen (voice)

Charlie McDowell as Madison (voice)

Mel Eslyn as Victoria (voice)

Jeremy Mackie as Other Male (voice)

Liz Lash as Other Female (voice)