Roger Davis as Stephen Foster Moody

Joan Hackett as Clementine Hale

Walter Brennan as Sheriff Matt Fenley

Wally Cox as Aaron Grimes / Ira Greebe

Pete Duel as 'Honest' John Smith

Skip Young as Desk Clerk

Steve Sandor as Parker

Robert Miller Driscoll as Harvey 'Fat' Chance

Richard Van Vleet as Randy Willis

Elliott Street as Railroad Ticket Clerk

Barbara Gates as Woman

Luis Delgado as Billings

Thomas Bellin as Dr. Mudd

Terrence Evans as Postmaster

Robert Gooden as 1st Player

James Jeter as Stagecoach Driver

Gregg Martell as Blacksmith

Jordan Rhodes as Train Brakeman