James Stewart as Grant McLaine

Audie Murphy as The Utica Kid

Dan Duryea as Whitey Harbin

Dianne Foster as Charlotte Drew

Elaine Stewart as Verna Kimball

Brandon De Wilde as Joey Adams

Jay C. Flippen as Ben Kimball

Herbert Anderson as Will Renner

Robert J. Wilke as Concho

Hugh Beaumont as Jeff Kurth

Jack Elam as Shotgun

Tommy Cook as Howdy Sladen

Paul Fix as Mr. Feeney

Olive Carey as Miss Vittles

James Flavin as Tim Riley

Donald Curtis as Jubilee

Ellen Corby as Mrs. Feeney

John Daheim as Latigo

Kenny Williams as O'Brien

Frank Chase as Trinidad

Harold Goodwin as Pick Gannon

Harold 'Tommy' Hart as Shannon

Jack C. Williams as Dusty

Boyd Stockman as Torgenson

Henry Wills as Pache

Chuck Roberson as Roan

Willard W. Willingham as Click

Polly Burson as Rosa

Patsy Novak as Linda

Ted Mapes as Leary

Emile Avery as Train Passenger (uncredited)

Jerry Brown as Train Passenger (uncredited)

Clem Fuller as Conductor (uncredited)

William Phillips as Blacksmith / Livery Stable Owner (uncredited)

Ben Welden as Pete (uncredited)