David Anders as Burt

Kandyse McClure as Vicki

Daniel Newman as Malachai

Preston Bailey as Issac

Robert Gerdisch as Preacher Boy

Jordan Schmidt as Bloody Knife Boy

Jake White as Oldest Boy

Zita Vass as Ponytail girl

Ryan Bertroche as Amos

Lexie Behr as Little Girl

Alexa Nikolas as Ruth

William Brent as Additional Voices (voice)

Regan Riley as Girl

Rylie Behr as Town Child

Brennan Bailey as Boy

Donald P. Borchers as Additional Voices (voice)

Leigh French as Additional Voices (voice)

Vien Hong as Additional Voices (voice)

Leo Howard as Additional Voices (voice)

Isabelle Fuhrman as Additional Voices (voice)

Emily Rose Everhard as Additional Voices (voice)

Max Burkholder as Additional Voices (voice)

James Burkholder as Additional Voices (voice)

Shawn Kelly as David

Paul Butler as Nahum

Aubrey Kratochville as Girl at Gas Station

Austin Coobs as Big Boy / Mark

Creighton Fox as Peter

Dominic Plue as Jacob

Austin Dreher as Freckled Boy

Remington Jennings as Joseph / Ahaz

Noah King as Town Child