Fredric March as Jonathan / Nathaniel / Samuel / Wallace Wooley

Veronica Lake as Jennifer

Robert Benchley as Dr. Dudley White

Susan Hayward as Estelle Masterson

Cecil Kellaway as Daniel

Elizabeth Patterson as Margaret

Robert Warwick as J. B. Masterson

Georgia Backus as Older Woman (uncredited)

Charles Bates as Wooley's Son (uncredited)

Brooks Benedict as Country Club Guest (uncredited)

Billy Bevan as Puritan Vendor (uncredited)

Edward Biby as Spectator at Fire (uncredited)

Marie Blake as Purity Sykes (uncredited)

Monte Blue as Doorman (uncredited)

Aldrich Bowker as Justice of the Peace (uncredited)

Al Bridge as Second Prison Guard (uncredited)

Nora Cecil as Harriet Wooley (uncredited)

Ann Carter as Jennifer Wooley (uncredited)

Chester Conklin as Party Bartender (uncredited)

Gordon De Main as Man with Masterson on Radio (uncredited)

Emma Dunn as Wife of Justice of the Peace (uncredited)

Ralph Dunn as First Prison Guard (uncredited)

Mary Field as Nancy Wooley (uncredited)

Bess Flowers as Matron of Honor (uncredited)

Joe Gilbert as Wedding Guest (uncredited)

Florence Gill as Woman Playing Chess (uncredited)

Robert Greig as Town Crier (uncredited)

Eily Malyon as Tabitha Wooley (uncredited)

Charles R. Moore as Rufus - Samuel's Servant (uncredited)

Viola Moore as Martha (uncredited)

Emory Parnell as Allen - Hotel Owner (uncredited)

Helen St. Rayner as Singer at Wedding (uncredited)

John Alban as

Beverly Andre as

Billy Bletcher as

Wade Boteler as

Eddy Chandler as

Georgie Cooper as

Gino Corrado as

Jack Deery as

Frank Elliott as

Franklyn Farnum as

Jack Gardner as

George Guhl as

William Haade as

Reed Hadley as

Oscar 'Dutch' Hendrian as

Robert Homans as

Esther Howard as Extra (uncredited)

Arthur Stuart Hull as

Donivee Lee as

Peter Leeds as

Jack Luden as

Renny McEvoy as

David McKim as

James Millican as

Frank Mills as

Edmund Mortimer as

Ralph Peters as

Gerald Pierce as

Mickey Rentschler as

Cyril Ring as

Ronald R. Rondell as

Loretta Russell as

Kathryn Sheldon as

Ernest Shields as

Lee Shumway as

Bert Stevens as

Amzie Strickland as

Harry Tyler as

Dan White as