Alicia Morton as Annie

Kathy Bates as Miss Agatha Hannigan

Victor Garber as Oliver Warbucks

Alan Cumming as Daniel Francis "Rooster" Hannigan

Audra McDonald as Miss Grace Farrell

Kristin Chenoweth as Lily St. Regis

Erin Adams as Tessie

Sarah Hyland as Molly

Lalaine as Kate

Nanea Miyata as July

Marissa Rago as Pepper

Danelle Wilson as Duffy

Andrea McArdle as Star-To-Be

Dennis Howard as F.D.R.

Douglas Fisher as Drake

Kurt Knudson as Justice Brandeis

Brooks Almy as Mrs. Pugh

Ruth Gottschall as Mrs. Greer

Tom Billett as 2nd Policeman

Frank Cavestani as Corn Vendor

Ellen Gerstein as Sophie

David Pevsner as Ira

Ed Francis Martin as Artie

Bob Morrisey as Dog Catcher

Kristin Quick as Orphan Sam

Linda Harmon as Boylan Sister (uncredited)