Dave Foley as Wayne (voice)

Sarah Chalke as Magee (voice)

Derek Richardson as Lanny (voice)

Mason Cotton as Timmy Terwelp (voice)

David DeLuise as Dancer (voice)

Peter Jacobson as Waterkotte (voice)

Lino DiSalvo as Gristletoe Joe (voice)

William Morgan Sheppard as Big Guy (voice)

Nathan Greno as Dasher (voice)

Hayes MacArthur as Thrasher (voice)

Kevin Deters as Brian (voice)

Kasha Kropinski as Miss Holly (voice)

Adam Shapiro as Coal Elf #1 (voice)

Stevie Wermers-Skelton as Rev-up elf (voice)