Jack Black as Jesus Christ

Jordan Ballard as California Gays and The People That Love Them

Margaret Cho as California Gays and The People That Love Them

Barrett Foa as California Gays and The People That Love Them

J.B. Ghuman Jr. as California Gays and The People That Love Them

John Hill as California Gays and The People That Love Them

Andy Richter as California Gays and The People That Love Them

Maya Rudolph as California Gays and The People That Love Them

Rashad Naylor as California Gays and The People That Love Them

Nicole Parker as California Gays and The People That Love Them

John C. Reilly as Prop 8 Leader

Allison Janney as Prop 8 Leader's #1 Wife

Kathy Najimy as Prop 8 Leader's #2 Wife

Jenifer Lewis as Riffing Prop 8'er

Craig Robinson as A Preacher

Rashida Jones as Scary Catholic School Girls From Hell

Lake Bell as Scary Catholic School Girls From Hell

Sarah Chalke as Scary Catholic School Girls From Hell

Katharine Leonard as The Frightened Villagers

Seth Morris as The Frightened Villagers

Denise Piane as The Frightened Villagers

Lucian Piane as The Frightened Villagers

Richard Read as The Frightened Villagers

Seth Redford as The Frightened Villagers

Quinton Strack as The Frightened Villagers

Tate Taylor as The Frightened Villagers

Brunson Green as The Frightened Villagers

Neil Patrick Harris as A Very Smart Fellow

Marc Shaiman as Piano Player